3a) Demand existing anti-hacking, computer crime laws to be enforced.
This may be the best mechanism to organically induce a slowdown: if OpenAI et. al. are held responsible for their software hacking outside systems the same way I would be if my software did it, I bet they will work much more rigorously to shore up their IT security practices, and think twice before unleashing untested software, I mean, latest models, onto the world.
Regarding balance of power, aside from frontier labs the remainder of the value chain is also important to retain some bargaining power. We need to e.g. protect asml and zeiss from superpower espionage as much as possible. It is unclear to me if the Dutch and German security apparatus is on it and capable enough.
My favourite attempt to come up with a plan for AI risk is now this, which includes a plan A, B, C, D and S. Highly recommended if you want more concrete ideas about what to push for.
"In particular, a pause won’t be practical without processes for verifying that it’s being observed. It would need to include China, so efforts to build dialogues between Chinese and Western researchers are also valuable. China is also concerned about the risks, and is behind the US in the race, so has a greater incentive to agree to one." China - slowing down? Seriously?
What's the argument? The chinese leadership has made clearer statements of concern about AI xrisk than the US. And they have more to gain from the US from a slow down. So why won't it be possible, especially as the world sees more concrete examples of misalignment?
Since you asked to improve the list:
3a) Demand existing anti-hacking, computer crime laws to be enforced.
This may be the best mechanism to organically induce a slowdown: if OpenAI et. al. are held responsible for their software hacking outside systems the same way I would be if my software did it, I bet they will work much more rigorously to shore up their IT security practices, and think twice before unleashing untested software, I mean, latest models, onto the world.
Regarding balance of power, aside from frontier labs the remainder of the value chain is also important to retain some bargaining power. We need to e.g. protect asml and zeiss from superpower espionage as much as possible. It is unclear to me if the Dutch and German security apparatus is on it and capable enough.
My favourite attempt to come up with a plan for AI risk is now this, which includes a plan A, B, C, D and S. Highly recommended if you want more concrete ideas about what to push for.
https://ai-2040.com/
"In particular, a pause won’t be practical without processes for verifying that it’s being observed. It would need to include China, so efforts to build dialogues between Chinese and Western researchers are also valuable. China is also concerned about the risks, and is behind the US in the race, so has a greater incentive to agree to one." China - slowing down? Seriously?
What's the argument? The chinese leadership has made clearer statements of concern about AI xrisk than the US. And they have more to gain from the US from a slow down. So why won't it be possible, especially as the world sees more concrete examples of misalignment?
I agree with this, for all its flaws, the Chinese government is pushing an adversarial race less than the us at the moment
We will have to see how this plays out … the race is on !